How To Make Butter Flavored Oil? (AVOID Doing This!)

Butter-flavored oil can be easily made at home with simple ingredients. You will simply need to combine butter extract and oil together. 

We are all guilty of indulging in too much butter in our meals. The delicious flavor of butter can make any dish turn heavenly.

However, there is one big problem with using butter regularly for making meals. Butter is actually extremely unhealthy and has tonnes of fats and sodium. 

The high-fat content makes it an unhealthy ingredient that may contribute to weight gain, diabetes, and cholesterol. This fact makes it rather difficult to indulge in butter without worrying about the consequences. 

Oil is a great substitute for butter when it comes to cooking. However, the distinct taste of butter is almost absent in all the oils that are found in the market.

What if I tell you that you can actually make butter-flavored oil at home? This article is going to shed some light on making butter oil at home and how you can use them for various dishes.

Step by Step Process to Make Butter Flavored Oil 

butter flavored oil

It is extremely easy to make butter-flavored oil. All you need are two ingredients (butter extract and oil) that need to be combined to make this delicious Oil.

People who want to make butter-flavored oil should have two ingredients handy. You need to have butter extract and the cooking oil of your choice for the recipe. 

The most common choices for cooking oil when making butter-flavored oil are olive oil, canola oil, and coconut oil. You can choose either of these oils depending on your preferences and budget constraints. 

Here is a detailed step-by-step process of making butter-flavored oil at home:-

  1. Take 1/2 cup olive oil and pour it out into a bowl.
  2. Use about 1 teaspoon of butter extract and add the ingredient into the bowl. 
  3. Combine the two ingredients until they appear uniform. (Make sure the extract doesn’t separate).
  4. Pour the mixture into a glass bottle and keep it in the refrigerator. 

After you have completed making the oil, you need to set it aside for future use. Refrigeration is extremely important because the butter extract may go bad if kept at normal temperature.

You can use this mix up to one month from the day you have made it. After one month, it is recommended to throw out excess oil and make a fresh batch for consumption. 

What Oil Tastes the Most Like Butter?

Olive oil tastes most like butter. Additionally, canola oil and coconut oil also have a mild buttery flavor.

Since butter is not the best ingredient for making meals daily, it’s better to use oils that taste like butter. My 14-year-old loves butter and has been consuming way too much of it.

To keep her from eating too much butter, I have discovered the recipe for making butter-flavored oil. She loves the flavor of the oil and never complains about not having butter in her meals.

From what I’ve gathered so far, olive oil has the most buttery flavor among all other varieties. It tastes almost exactly like butter.

Before I discovered the recipe for butter-flavored oil, I preferred using olive oil for cooking and flavoring my meals. If the buttery flavor of olive oil is not enough, you can add butter extracts and turn them into your custom butter oil.

Best Butter Flavored Cooking Oils in the Market

Butter flavored oilPrices 
Mantova Grand’ Aroma Truffle Flavored Extra Virgin Olive Oil$12.95/250ml
Whirl Butter Oil$20.99/gallon
Robert’s Extra Virgin Infused Olive Oil – Butter$38.99/750ml
LeRoux Kitchen Butter Flavored Olive Oil$34.99/750ml
Secolarievoo Butter Olive Oil (Mantequilla)$26.50/375ml

There are a variety of butter-flavored oils available in the market. If you don’t feel like making a batch at home, you can simply buy them online or at a store. You will find them on amazon, Walmart, Walgreens, and Costco.

If you are looking for good butter-flavored oil, you can try some of my top recommendations from here:-

1. Mantova Grand’ Aroma Truffle Flavored Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Mantova Grand Aroma Truffle oil is a great luxury oil that is flavored with white Truffle extract. The oil has a rich earthy and buttery flavor that makes it the perfect ingredient for continental dishes.

2. Whirl Butter Oil 

Whirl butter oil is a great alternative to dairy butter and is made with soybean paste. It is a gluten-free vegan option for people who want to enjoy butter-flavored oil without unhealthy ingredients.

3. Robert’s Extra Virgin Infused Olive Oil – Butter

Robert’s olive oil is available in butter flavor along with many others. The oil is slightly on the expensive side but the delectable taste makes up for the price.

4. LeRoux Kitchen Butter Flavored Olive Oil

LeRoux is a gourmet brand that specializes in making butter-flavored olive oil. The oil is made in the USA and has a distinct buttery flavor that is perfect for a delicious dinner.

5. Secolarievoo Butter Olive Oil (Mantequilla)

Secolarievoo Butter Olive Oil is an amazing butter-flavored oil that is easily available in the supermarket. It is moderately priced and good for making pasta and salad.

Using Butter Flavored Oil With Popcorn

Butter-flavored oil can be used for a variety of cuisines. It tastes exceptionally well with homemade Popcorn.

To make the perfect homemade popcorn with butter-flavored oil, you need to pop the corn kernels and set them aside. Before you decide to eat your popcorn, drizzle some butter-flavored oil on your popcorn and shake the container to mix.

Make sure you coat all the kernels with the oil for the ultimate taste. You can also add some chili powder or cajun seasoning to add a little zing.

Final Remarks 

Flavored oils are extremely delicious and can transform the flavor of any dish you make. You can also add some amazing ingredients like chili and garlic to elevate the flavor of the oil.

Butter oil is very easy to make and only requires two ingredients. Additionally, it can be made at home and used for up to a month.

Here is a quick recap about butter-flavored oil which I’ve discussed so far.

It is very easy to make butter-flavored oil at home. You simply need to add butter extract to olive oil and mix it together to make a consistent oil.